Encrypted | Login

Policy number Policy name Policy date Sunset date
AP 115-A Guidelines for Presentation of TG, WG, and MPPG Reports at AAPM Meetings 12/14/2020 12/31/2025
Policy source
EXCOM December 14, 2020 Meeting
Policy text

Background:

One of the most valued activities of AAPM is the production of Medical Physics Practice Guidelines (MPPGs) and Task Group reports (TGs). However, the presentation of this work at meetings of the AAPM is highly variable. Over the time period of 2015 to 2017, 19 reports were published. However, only 12 of these were presented at either an Annual Meeting or a Spring Clinical Meeting (i.e. approximately 40% of reports were never presented). On the other hand, some reports are “over-presented”. In the same time period, 5 reports were presented more than once, with one report being presented more than 7 times in a 3-year period.

There are numerous advantages to having reports presented at meetings including the following: 1) enhance the quality of the meeting (such presentations are uniformly well-received), 2) allow for discussion, 3) make the material more accessible, and 4) allow for availability in the online library. This latter is also valuable for the education of students, resident and junior physicists.

In addition, in the past some TGs have presented their results while the work of the TG is still in the early stages, and there have been substantial changes made during the subsequent review processes. This can be confusing to those who attended the presentation or who view it on the virtual library. Also, it is difficult for physicists to follow up on recommendations given in presentations if the actual report/paper isn’t published/made available for several years.

Guidelines:

  1. These guidelines apply to all public presentations.
  2. Requirements for presenting
    1. Presentation of final results/recommendations of the Group
      1. Reports/papers must have minimally reached the stage of Council level approval by the time the invitation to present is issued.
      2. All presentations must be SAM and recorded for inclusion in the virtual library
    2. For presentations in which the Group is requesting feedback from the medical physics community to help them address their charges:
      1. The Group must have support for the presentation by their parent organization (WG, subcommittee, committee, or Council).
      2. The title of the meeting presentation and abstract must make it clear that this is not a presentation of final findings/recommendations. The speaker must also state the same during the presentation.
    3. AAPM reports/papers may not be submitted or presented as proffered talks. Reports will be presented as invited symposia.
  3. Capture and presentation of reports fulfilling requirements
    1. MCC and AAPM Headquarters staff will devise a methodology to notify MCC when a report has received Council approval. MCC will keep a list of reports ready for presentation.
    2. MCC will determine at which meeting a report will be presented. The Group and/or its parent committees may request a specific meeting, but the final decision will be made by MCC.
    3. TG Chairs are strongly encouraged to submit independently to the selected meeting's RFP.
    4. In rare cases, Groups or the meeting organizers may request that a report not be presented. Non-presentation requires consent of the respective Council.
  4. Multiple presentations at AAPM meetings
    1. All reports will be presented at only one national AAPM meeting.
      1. As an invited talk, the presentation will be recorded and available in the Virtual Library.
      2. Exception will be made for reports deemed to be of high importance to a large fraction of the membership, such as TG100. Exceptions must be requested by the respective Council or EXCOM.
    2. Additional presentation at AAPM Chapter meetings is allowed.
  5. Non-AAPM Meetings
    1. Reports presented at AAPM Meetings may also be presented at non-AAPM meetings (e.g. ASTRO and RSNA). The requirements for presentation specified in section 2 (except 2.a.ii) hold for all non-AAPM meetings. 

 

Policy version history
Policy number Policy name Policy date Sunset date Active?
AP 115-A Guidelines for Presentation of TG, WG, and MPPG Reports at AAPM Meetings 12/14/2020 12/31/2025 Active

Return to